Edinburgh's Book Festival starts properly tomorrow, but there was a special event, in conjunction with BBC Arts, in the George Street theatre this morning on the novels that shaped our world. Prefacing a series on radio and television this autumn to mark the 300th anniversary of the publication of Robinson Crusoe - considered to be the first English language novel - the event co-opted three members of the six-strong panel which has been choosing 100 novels of significance and asked them to outline the criteria with which they compiled their list and discuss what reading means to them. Edinburgh's own Alexander McCall Smith, novelist Kit de Waal, and TLS editor Stig Abell joined Joe Haddow, producer of Radio 2's Book Club, for an hour of lively chat with plenty of audience participation.
While the panel felt that reading is "entertainment, first and foremost," a book's ability to "change us, move us, and give us a different view of something," should not be underestimated; "that's what literature is for," said Kit. Stig, a frequent re-reader, talked of (re-)reading for solace and comfort and escape, and noted that re-reading at different stages in life enriches our impressions, understanding, and perspective. Context and even location while reading were both accorded due significance, as was the influence - for good or ill - of English teachers.
The panel were unanimous in their condemnation of showing off about books, literary snobbery, and failing to respect others' tastes, no matter the preferred genre, though they made one exception to this, namely books which are badly written. Their list is, however, driven by admiration and the desire to share good things, as we might say to a friend, "I love this - do read it."
In choosing their 100 they have identified a number of overlapping themes such as identity, class and society, coming of age, love, power, and so on. Questioned on what drew him particularly, Sandy said it was a sense of place, rather than a specific theme or type of plot, to which he responded most and he gave Forster's A Passage to India and the works of R.K. Narayan* as prime examples.
Asked to name a book which had shaped them, several members of the audience contributed: War and Peace was cited for its deft portrayal of relationships, the subtleties of behaviour, and the futility of war; Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, so much more than its legacy in popular culture; Alan Garner's The Weirdstone of Brisingamen continues to transport a reader who first discovered it aged eight when it "taught [her] magic - of the book variety." Other works mentioned included The Member of the Wedding by Carson McCullers for its articulation of loneliness and introduction to American literature, Pride and Prejudice for initiating a shift in a young reader's path in life, and Daphne du Maurier's Rebecca for providing solace at a difficult time. Jane Eyre still connects a lady with the grandmother who bought a copy for her in Woolworths when she was ten years old. It unlocked her imagination, she said, and opened up "the inner life that can forever sustain you."
Above all, perhaps, it was the power of literature to foster empathy which was deemed its most important characteristic, one that is surely even more valuable in these troubled times.
*The book group read The Painter of Signs.